Nutritious Cheese
Premium Meat
Delicious Chocolate
Troyer’s Trail Bologna
Troyer’s Trail BolognaPrice is for a 1 1/2 Lb. ring. Weight is approximate and may vary.
One of the best flavors of Amish Country!
$10.99Add to cart
Ohio Swiss Cheese
Ohio Swiss CheesePrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.
$7.99Add to cart
Baby Swiss Cheese
Baby Swiss Cheese-
$10.99 – $40.99Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Baby Swiss Cheese
Baby Swiss Cheese$10.99 – $40.99Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Amish Butter Cheese
Amish Butter CheesePrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
$7.99Add to cart
Streb Meats Fresh Pork Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 2 Lb.
Streb Meats Fresh Pork Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 2 Lb.-
$7.99Add to cart
Streb Meats Fresh Pork Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 2 Lb.
Streb Meats Fresh Pork Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 2 Lb.Streb Meats Fresh Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones)
Not the reconstituted pork rinds you get from the local grocery store! Excellent for low-carb diets.
$7.99Add to cart
Lebanon Bologna
Lebanon Bologna-
$10.99 – $13.99Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Lebanon Bologna
Lebanon Bologna$10.99 – $13.99Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Rolled Amish Butter
Rolled Amish Butter-
$10.19 – $11.29Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Rolled Amish Butter
Rolled Amish ButterPer Lb. Salted or Unsalted.
$10.19 – $11.29Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Sweet Lebanon Bologna
Sweet Lebanon Bologna-
$10.99 – $13.99Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Sweet Lebanon Bologna
Sweet Lebanon BolognaLebanon bologna is a type of cured, smoked, fermented, semi-dry sausage. The highest quality lean beef, carefully ground and cured with aromatic spices.
$10.99 – $13.99Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Ghost Pepper Cheese
Ghost Pepper CheeseSuper Hot Ghost Pepper Cheese. 855,000 Scoville units of heat! Careful, it will sneak up on you!
$13.99Add to cart
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination-
$65.00Add to cart
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination$65.00Add to cart
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese-
$35.00Add to cart
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese$35.00Add to cart
Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked Bacon
Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked Bacon-
$11.99Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked Bacon
Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked BaconPrice is Per Lb. Weight may vary up to 10%
$11.99Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)-
$4.49Add to cart
Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)$4.49Add to cart
Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts (8 Oz.)-
$10.79Read more
Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts (8 Oz.)$10.79Read more
Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.
Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.-
$5.99Add to cart
Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.
Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.$5.99Add to cart
Ben Heggy’s Whole Cashew Nuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Whole Cashew Nuts (8 Oz.)-
$13.49Add to cart
Ben Heggy’s Whole Cashew Nuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Whole Cashew Nuts (8 Oz.)$13.49Add to cart
Carolina Reaper Cheese
Carolina Reaper CheeseCarolina Reaper Cheese is currently the hottest cheese we have to offer with up to 2.2 million Scoville units of heat!
$13.99Add to cart
Double Cream Gouda
Double Cream Gouda-
$12.99 – $23.99Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Double Cream Gouda
Double Cream Gouda$12.99 – $23.99Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Ghost Pepper Cheese
Ghost Pepper CheeseSuper Hot Ghost Pepper Cheese. 855,000 Scoville units of heat! Careful, it will sneak up on you!
$13.99Add to cart
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese-
$35.00Add to cart
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese$35.00Add to cart
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese-
$35.00Add to cart
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese$35.00Add to cart
Gift Box #4: Amish Cheese and Goodies
Gift Box #4: Amish Cheese and Goodies-
$55.00Add to cart
Gift Box #4: Amish Cheese and Goodies
Gift Box #4: Amish Cheese and Goodies$55.00Add to cart
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination-
$65.00Add to cart
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination$65.00Add to cart
Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box
Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box-
$85.00Add to cart
Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box
Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box$85.00Add to cart
Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box
Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box-
$125.00Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box
Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box$125.00Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Gift Box #8: Shisler’s Cheese House Luxury Gift Box
Gift Box #8: Shisler’s Cheese House Luxury Gift Box-
$85.00Add to cart
Gift Box #8: Shisler’s Cheese House Luxury Gift Box
Gift Box #8: Shisler’s Cheese House Luxury Gift Box$85.00Add to cart
Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift Card
Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift CardShisler’s Cheez-E-Gift Card
Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift CardThe perfect Gift! These gift certificates can be used all at once or for multiple transactions. Four denominations available.
Our Little Cheese House, Established In 1958, Is The Best Place To Buy Cheese Online!
Welcome to Shisler’s Cheese House! The best place to buy cheese online. While cheese is our biggest product, we also have various meats and sweets! We hope that you enjoy our Orrville-based cheese, and if you have any questions contact us today!
icon-clock
Latest Blogs
Best Cheeses from Around the World: A Journey Through International Cheese Varieties and Their Origins
The best cheeses are found in all four corners of the world. Cheese is more than just a delicious food
The Nutritional Value Of Cheese (Health Insights)
The nutritional value of cheese is not exactly something people talk about often. This satisfying, tasty, and tangy
A Quick Look at the History of Cheese Making Through the Ages
The history of cheese is as rich and varied as the many types of cheese we enjoy today. Cheese-making
The Ultimate Guide to Different Cheeses: Explore Various Cheese Categories
Let’s explore the different cheeses and their types. From soft, creamy bries to sharp, tangy cheddars, the
How To Host the Perfect Cheese and Wine Tasting at Home
Planning a memorable cheese and wine tasting at home can be a simple affair.
With the right selection of
Which Cheese For Pasta: Parmesan vs Romano Pecorino
If the question “Which cheese for pasta?” is burning in your mind and you are trying to choose between Parmesan
An Easy Summer Quiche Recipe
Here is an easy summer quiche recipe you will keep making, full of rich and creamy flavors like bacon and
Why Does Cheese Go Moldy?
You may be wondering, why does cheese go moldy? Cheese lovers all over the world have been asking the same
Build The Perfect Charcuterie Board
Build the perfect charcuterie board and cultivate confidence in entertaining.
A beautifully curated charcuterie board is a fun way to
Our Customers Feeback
Kim K., Vermillion, OH
“I absolutely love this little cheese shop! The workers are always friendly and welcoming. Plenty of selection and that down home feeling of an authentic country store! Our relatives from afar always look forward to a gift box from Shislers – it’s become me a tradition!!”
Jim Cummins
When our family left Ohio thirty years ago, we didn’t forget Shisler’s Cheese House. Having patronized Shisler’s while living close enough to shop there personally, beginning as children. We continued to do so from eight different states over the years, in which we lived. That’s because you can’t find better products (meats and cheeses) even in Wisconsin! Buy with confidence and spread the word by introducing others to Shisler’s Cheese House and their products and service. Guaranteed, your friends won’t find comparable quality where they live. We’re back in Ohio, now, and continue sending gifts to friends. You should make Shisler’s a big part of your gift giving, too!
IAmNotAFunguy
Nice little place. Owned and run by a very nice family. The cheese and candy are all homemade and always to the highest of age and quality and the beef is farmed fresh from right nearby. Worth the stop if you come out here.
Stacy Adams
Love the cheese here! Family store. Ladies working are always so friendly even close to closing time. They also have good trail bologna and they carry the best heggys chocolates too! 🙂
Adrian Smith
Nothing compares! When I’m in Wooster visiting I load up on five items cheese, trail, chips,candy and various other cheeses. When in SC I call in orders and watch for UPS truck. Now other family members are doing the same. Love you Rita!!
Beth Bytheway Lehman
I have shopped here since I was a little girl! Always great to taste food from my childhood: Trail baloney, Streb’s sausage, Swiss cheese, cheese curds, Heggy’s Chocolates…..
Amanda Pigeon
I have been coming into Shisler’s since before I was born in Orrville, Ohio! I now travel from Wisconsin, and it is a planned, much anticipated, part of a trip home. Everybody there feels like family, and the cheese!! Oh, the cheese is amazing, some of our favorites being the 3yr aged sharp white cheddar, and the Amish Butter cheese. Sausages, mustards, and let’s not forget Hegge’s Chocolates!! See you soon, Rita!!
John Sullivan
Support and response has been amazing, helping me with several issues I came across and got them solved almost the same day. A pleasure to work with them!
Jenifer Brown
Support and response has been amazing, helping me with several issues I came across and got them solved almost the same day. A pleasure to work with them!
Kathy Young
Support and response has been amazing, helping me with several issues I came across and got them solved almost the same day. A pleasure to work with them!
Doe John
Support and response has been amazing, helping me with several issues I came across and got them solved almost the same day. A pleasure to work with them!