Chocolate Cheese? 6 Ways to Eat this Unusual Treat

We know what you’re thinking. Surely, you can’t have chocolate and cheese? But we’re here to tell you that at Shisler’s Cheese House, you can, in fact, have both! Our chocolate cheese is made from a local recipe and all locally produced ingredients combining fine chocolate fudge with premium cream cheese. The result is the perfect smooth and … Read more

About Ohio Amish Country

The Amish Communities are a big part of Shisler’s Cheese House. We pride ourselves in using local trade, producers, and Cheesemakers when we can. It is important to us as just as much as our customers, especially our regulars because you’re what keep us going. With everything over the years changing and becoming more modernized … Read more

Christmas At Shisler’s Cheese House

It’s amazing how fast the year passes by. It feels like just yesterday that we were picking up our Easter chocolate and gift boxes from Shisler’s Cheese House. With Christmas just around the corner, it is time to start thinking about what gifts would be ideal for our family and friends. A lot of the … Read more

Enjoy These WonderFALL Treats At Shisler’s Cheese House!

Fall is such a refreshing time of the year, the kids are back at school, the weather is cooling down, Halloween is just around the corner and most importantly, the Football Season has begun! Come on down to Shisler’s Cheese House and check out these amazing gift boxes packed with dreamy treats for our Fall … Read more

Fleur de Sel Soft Caramels

Salt is becoming more popular by the day to accompany chocolate, sugar, and cream in delicious desserts. This is because salt gives a huge burst of flavor like no other, be it in a sweet or savory dish. In this particular dessert, salt is a delightful counterpoint to rich and sweet caramel which helps it … Read more

For All The Coffee Lovers Out There: Coffee Chocolate Truffles

Mmmm two of the best consumables in the world besides cheese- coffee and chocolate! Although coffee and chocolate is a common trend in foods, it is not easy to make perfectly delicious truffles especially when this recipe calls for you to use coffee instead of cream to make these lactose-free tastes of heaven. In this … Read more

Chocolate Creations Part Three: Chocolate Butter

If you’re looking for something different for dessert, this is definitely the way to go! Served at room temperature with your favorite bread, you can pass the chocolate butter around and let everyone spread their own chocolate on their toast. There is so much you can do with this delicious recipe, be it spreading it … Read more

Chocolate Creations Part Two: Homemade S’mores

S’mores are an all-time American favorite, they take us back to times when life was much simpler, sitting by a campfire with our friends, singing campfire songs and burning the marshmallow to our s’more was our only worry. Let’s get back that delicious piece of childhood by taking it to the next level and making … Read more

Chocolate Creations Part One: Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

You may love store-bought varieties of peanut butter cups, but once you taste these homemade ones, you will never go back! Made with rich dark chocolate, they are oozing with an irresistable flavor that will leave you wanting more. Recipe Makes: 24 pieces What You Need: 3/4 cup smooth peanut butter 15 oz. dark ground … Read more