Shop
Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)- Sku: 261
- Availability: In Stock
Ben Heggy’s Fancy Mixed Nuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Fancy Mixed Nuts (8 Oz.)- Sku: SKU - 264
- Availability: In Stock
Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts (8 Oz.)Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts (8 Oz.)- Sku: SKU - 262
- Availability: In Stock
Ben Heggy’s Roasted Pecans (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Roasted Pecans (8 Oz.)- Sku: SKU - 265
- Availability: In Stock
Ben Heggy’s Spanish Peanuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Spanish Peanuts (8 Oz.)- Sku: SKU - 260
- Availability: In Stock
Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.
Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.
Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.- Sku: 259
- Availability: In Stock
Ben Heggy’s Whole Cashew Nuts (8 Oz.)
Ben Heggy’s Whole Cashew Nuts (8 Oz.)- Sku: SKU - 263
- Availability: In Stock
Bread Cheese (8-10 oz)
Bread Cheese (8-10 oz)- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Caraway Cheese
Caraway Cheese- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Carolina Reaper Cheese
Carolina Reaper CheeseCarolina Reaper Cheese
Carolina Reaper CheeseCarolina Reaper Cheese is currently the hottest cheese we have to offer with up to 2.2 million Scoville units of heat!
- Sku: 344-1
- Availability: In Stock
Chocolate Buckeyes
Chocolate Buckeyes- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Cognac Fig Goat Cheese (4.5oz)
Cognac Fig Goat Cheese (4.5oz)- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Double Cream Gouda
Double Cream Gouda- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Easter Gift Baskets
Easter Gift Baskets- Sku: SKU - 283
- Availability: Out of Stock
Ghost Pepper Cheese
Ghost Pepper CheeseGhost Pepper Cheese
Ghost Pepper CheeseSuper Hot Ghost Pepper Cheese. 855,000 Scoville units of heat! Careful, it will sneak up on you!
- Sku: 343
- Availability: In Stock
Gift Box #1: Baby Swiss Cheese
Gift Box #1: Baby Swiss Cheese- Sku: 20
- Availability: In Stock
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and CheeseGift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese- Sku: 110
- Availability: In Stock
Gift Box #3: Cheese Lover’s
Gift Box #3: Cheese Lover’s- Sku: SKU - 111
- Availability: In Stock
Gift Box #4: Amish Cheese and Goodies
Gift Box #4: Amish Cheese and GoodiesGift Box #4: Amish Cheese and Goodies
Gift Box #4: Amish Cheese and Goodies- Sku: SKU - 112
- Availability: In Stock
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country CombinationGift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination- Sku: 113
- Availability: In Stock
Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box
Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift BoxGift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box
Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box- Sku: SKU - 114
- Availability: In Stock
Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box
Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift BoxGift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box
Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box- Sku: SKU - 114-1
- Availability: In Stock
Gift Box for Dad: Unique Fathers Day Gifts
Gift Box for Dad: Unique Fathers Day GiftsGift Box for Dad: Unique Fathers Day Gifts
Gift Box for Dad: Unique Fathers Day Gifts- Sku: SKU - 268
- Availability: In Stock
Glacier Wildfire Blue Cheese
Glacier Wildfire Blue Cheese- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Gourmet Chocolate Covered Pretzels
Gourmet Chocolate Covered PretzelsGourmet Chocolate Covered Pretzels
Gourmet Chocolate Covered PretzelsClassic Animal Crackers dipped in Stefanelli’s Candies signature decadent chocolate
- Sku: SKU - 341
- Availability: In Stock
Honey Spread (1.5 oz)
Honey Spread (1.5 oz)- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Jalapeno Havarti
Jalapeno Havarti- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Locally Made Fresh Maple Syrup
Locally Made Fresh Maple SyrupLocally Made Fresh Maple Syrup
Locally Made Fresh Maple Syrup- Sku: SKU - 276
- Availability: In Stock
Mango Fire Cheddar Cheese
Mango Fire Cheddar Cheese- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Mini Chocolate Buckeyes (8oz)
Mini Chocolate Buckeyes (8oz)- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Natural Smoked Swiss Cheese
Natural Smoked Swiss Cheese- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Pesto Goat Cheese (4.5 oz)
Pesto Goat Cheese (4.5 oz)- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Pizza Flavored Cheese
Pizza Flavored Cheese- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Rolled Amish Butter
Rolled Amish Butter- Sku: 235
- Availability: In Stock
Scorpion Cheddar
Scorpion CheddarScorpion Cheddar
Scorpion CheddarScorpion cheddar is currently the second hottest cheese we have to offer with 1.2 million scoville units of heat!
- Sku: 344
- Availability: In Stock
Shisler’s Cheese House Gift Mug with Heggy’s Chocolate
Shisler’s Cheese House Gift Mug with Heggy’s ChocolateShisler’s Cheese House Gift Mug with Heggy’s Chocolate
Shisler’s Cheese House Gift Mug with Heggy’s Chocolate- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift Card
Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift CardShisler’s Cheez-E-Gift Card
Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift CardThe perfect Gift! These gift certificates can be used all at once or for multiple transactions. Four denominations available.
- Sku: 303
- Availability: In Stock
Shisler’s Fig Jam
Shisler’s Fig Jam- Sku: SKU - 256
- Availability: In Stock
Shisler’s Private Label Hot Jalapeno Mustard (8 Oz.)
Shisler’s Private Label Hot Jalapeno Mustard (8 Oz.)Shisler’s Private Label Hot Jalapeno Mustard (8 Oz.)
Shisler’s Private Label Hot Jalapeno Mustard (8 Oz.)- Sku: SKU - 157
- Availability: In Stock
Shisler’s Private Label Old Fashioned Apple Butter (16 Oz.)
Shisler’s Private Label Old Fashioned Apple Butter (16 Oz.)Shisler’s Private Label Old Fashioned Apple Butter (16 Oz.)
Shisler’s Private Label Old Fashioned Apple Butter (16 Oz.)- Sku: SKU - 253
- Availability: In Stock
Shisler’s Private Label Quince Jelly (18 Oz.)
Shisler’s Private Label Quince Jelly (18 Oz.)Shisler’s Private Label Quince Jelly (18 Oz.)
Shisler’s Private Label Quince Jelly (18 Oz.)- Sku: SKU - 254
- Availability: In Stock
Shisler’s Private Label Roasted Garlic Mustard (8 Oz.)
Shisler’s Private Label Roasted Garlic Mustard (8 Oz.)Shisler’s Private Label Roasted Garlic Mustard (8 Oz.)
Shisler’s Private Label Roasted Garlic Mustard (8 Oz.)- Sku: SKU - 180
- Availability: In Stock
Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Mustard (8 Oz.)
Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Mustard (8 Oz.)Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Mustard (8 Oz.)
Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Mustard (8 Oz.)- Sku: SKU - 179
- Availability: In Stock
Sponge Candy
Sponge CandySponge Candy
Sponge CandySponge candy, delectable sea foam toffee covered in rich chocolate. Be careful, it’s addictive!
- Sku: SKU - 338
- Availability: In Stock
Streb Meats Boneless Smoked Ham
Streb Meats Boneless Smoked Ham- Sku: SKU - 161
- Availability: In Stock
Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked Bacon
Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked BaconStreb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked Bacon
Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked BaconPrice is Per Lb. Weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: 160
- Availability: In Stock
Streb Meats Fresh Pork Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 1/2Lb.
Streb Meats Fresh Pork Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 1/2Lb.Streb Meats Fresh Pork Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 1/2Lb.
Streb Meats Fresh Pork Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 1/2Lb.Streb Meats Fresh Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones)
Not the reconstituted pork rinds you get from the local grocery store! Excellent for low-carb diets.
- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
Streb Meats Fresh Smoked Sausage
Streb Meats Fresh Smoked SausageStreb Meats Fresh Smoked Sausage
Streb Meats Fresh Smoked SausagePrice is per Lb. Weight may vary up to 10%.
- Sku: SKU - 163
- Availability: In Stock
Valentines Day Gift Box for Her
Valentines Day Gift Box for HerValentines Day Gift Box for Her
Valentines Day Gift Box for Her- Sku: SKU - 267
- Availability: In Stock
Veteran’s Care Package
Veteran’s Care Package- Sku: 250
- Availability: In Stock
White Wine Cheese Collection
White Wine Cheese Collection- Sku: 236
- Availability: In Stock
Wild Maple Walnut Syrup
Wild Maple Walnut Syrup- Sku: SKU - 269
- Availability: In Stock
4 In 1 Cheese
4 In 1 Cheese- Sku: SKU - 18
- Availability: In Stock
American Cheese
American Cheese- Sku: SKU - 19
- Availability: In Stock
Amish Butter Cheese
Amish Butter Cheese- Sku: 24
- Availability: In Stock
Asiago Cheese
Asiago Cheese- Sku: 21
- Availability: In Stock
Baby Swiss Cheese
Baby Swiss Cheese- Sku: SKU - 25
- Availability: In Stock
Bacon Cheese
Bacon Cheese- Sku: 27
- Availability: In Stock
Beer Cheese
Beer CheeseBeer Cheese
Beer CheesePrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%. It is a semi-soft combination of Limburger Cheese and Brick Cheese.
- Sku: 28
- Availability: In Stock
Beer Collection
Beer Collection- Sku: 238
- Availability: In Stock
Bermuda Onion Cheese
Bermuda Onion Cheese- Sku: 29
- Availability: In Stock
Blackberry Pecan Syrup
Blackberry Pecan Syrup- Sku: 272
- Availability: Out of Stock
Blueberry Syrup
Blueberry Syrup- Sku: SKU - 273
- Availability: In Stock
Brick Cheese
Brick Cheese- Sku: 223
- Availability: In Stock
Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged Cheddar
Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged CheddarCanadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged Cheddar
Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged CheddarPrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: 30
- Availability: In Stock
Chevre Goat’s Milk Cheese
Chevre Goat’s Milk Cheese- Sku: SKU - 55
- Availability: In Stock
Cinnamon Sticky Bun Syrup
Cinnamon Sticky Bun Syrup- Sku: 270
- Availability: In Stock
Colby Cheese
Colby Cheese- Sku: 34
- Availability: In Stock
Danish Blue Cheese
Danish Blue CheeseDanish Blue Cheese
Danish Blue CheesePrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: 35
- Availability: In Stock
Farmer’s Cheese
Farmer’s Cheese- Sku: SKU - 38
- Availability: In Stock
Football Season Special
Football Season Special- Sku: SKU - 242
- Availability: In Stock
Garlic Cheddar
Garlic Cheddar- Sku: SKU - 40
- Availability: In Stock
Goat Cheese
Goat Cheese- Sku: SKU - 41
- Availability: In Stock
Gouda
GoudaGreen Onion Cheese
Green Onion Cheese- Sku: 39
- Availability: In Stock
Gruyere Cheese
Gruyere Cheese- Sku: SKU - 43
- Availability: In Stock
Havarti Cheese
Havarti Cheese- Sku: SKU - 36
- Availability: In Stock
Havarti Cheese With Caraway
Havarti Cheese With CarawayHavarti Cheese With Caraway
Havarti Cheese With CarawayPrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: 31
- Availability: In Stock
Havarti Cheese With Dill
Havarti Cheese With DillHavarti Cheese With Dill
Havarti Cheese With DillPrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: 37
- Availability: In Stock
Heggy’s Assortment
Heggy’s Assortment- Sku: 109
- Availability: In Stock
Homestyle Jams
Homestyle Jams- Sku: SKU - 117
- Availability: In Stock
Horseradish Cheddar
Horseradish Cheddar- Sku: SKU - 46
- Availability: In Stock
Hot Habanero Cheddar
Hot Habanero Cheddar- Sku: SKU - 44
- Availability: In Stock
Hot Pepper Cheese
Hot Pepper Cheese- Sku: SKU - 47
- Availability: In Stock
Hot Pepper Jelly
Hot Pepper Jelly- Sku: SKU - 128
- Availability: In Stock
Jarlsberg® Cheese
Jarlsberg® Cheese- Sku: 49
- Availability: In Stock
Jumping Jack
Jumping Jack- Sku: 50
- Availability: In Stock
Lacey Baby Swiss
Lacey Baby Swiss- Sku: SKU - 26
- Availability: In Stock
Lacy Swiss
Lacy Swiss- Sku: 15
- Availability: In Stock
Lavender Syrup
Lavender Syrup- Sku: 275
- Availability: In Stock
Limburger Cheese (8 oz.)
Limburger Cheese (8 oz.)Limburger Cheese (8 oz.)
Limburger Cheese (8 oz.)Price is per 6 oz. piece. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.
Smooth & Creamy with an intense smell & flavor
- Sku: 52
- Availability: In Stock
Manchego Cheese
Manchego Cheese- Sku: SKU - 54
- Availability: In Stock
Marble Cheese
Marble Cheese- Sku: SKU - 51
- Availability: In Stock
Mozzarella
Mozzarella- Sku: SKU - 56
- Availability: In Stock
Muenster Cheese
Muenster Cheese- Sku: SKU - 57
- Availability: In Stock
Ohio Swiss Cheese
Ohio Swiss Cheese- Sku: 14
- Availability: In Stock